On being nonbinary, recognition, and the courage to trust yourself in a world that has no box for you
There’s a specific moment that most nonbinary people only recognise in hindsight.
It’s not spectacular. No fanfare. It looks roughly like this: you’re sitting somewhere — on a bus, at work, in school, at university, in a café, in bed at three in the morning — and something inside you says, quietly but precisely: I’m not this. What they tell me I am — I’m not.
And immediately after, a second voice. Louder. More rehearsed. Saying: don’t be ridiculous. It’s a phase. It’s the internet. It’s because you’re not strong enough to be normal, to fit in. You’re just a weirdo.
That second voice — it’s not yours. But it sounds like it is, because you’ve been hearing it your whole life.
This piece is for you if you’ve ever thought you might be nonbinary — and immediately feared that thought. If you treated a thought about yourself like a symptom. If your response to your own recognition was to try to shut it down.
Recognition Is Not a Symptom
One of the hardest things about the nonbinary experience is that it has no ready-made narrative. Trans women and trans men who fit within the binary model of gender — however difficult their struggles — at least have a cultural template for their story: “I knew since childhood,” “I felt trapped in the wrong body.” Those sentences, however reductive, exist in the language. The world recognises them, even when it doesn’t accept them.
Nonbinary experience has no such narrative. Or it has one only in the last decade, mostly in English, mostly in spaces invisible to most people. Most languages don’t recognise this experience and lack the resources to express it — which is why you didn’t have words for what you felt. You didn’t even know a category existed where your experience could fit.
And then, when you finally enter a space where someone says “nonbinary” — you recognise yourself — and what happens inside you?
Fear happens.
Because recognition without cultural support has no ground to hold that experience.
Imagine it differently. Imagine a person who has spoken a language their whole life that no one around them speaks. Everyone tells them that language doesn’t exist. And then one day they hear someone speaking the same language — and think: “Wait, so I wasn’t hallucinating?” But immediately after: “But what if I was?”
That’s nonbinary recognition. The feeling that you’ve finally found something real — and the simultaneous terror that you made it up.
Where the Feeling of Being Broken Comes From
Let’s be precise: you didn’t sit down one day and decide to doubt yourself. It happened slowly. Over years. Through thousands of small messages telling you how the world works.
Cisnormativity — the system built on the assumption that everyone is cis, that binary gender is the only reality, and that anything outside it is an aberration — doesn’t function as explicit law. It functions as air. You don’t see it until you’re running out.
When you’re a child growing up in a world with only two genders, and your experience belongs to neither — your brain does the only thing it knows: it adapts. Picks a side. Performs. Puts on a costume. And keeps doing it for years, decades, until the costume starts to feel like it’s fused to your skin.
And then, when you finally recognise that the costume was never yours — that you’ve spent your whole life wearing something borrowed — you feel like a fraud. Because if you take off the costume, who are you then? What’s left?
What’s left is what was always there. You just didn’t have permission to see it.
What you experience as “brokenness” — that feeling that something is fundamentally wrong with you, that you should be simpler, more legible, more normal — that’s internalised cisnormativity. Just as internalised homophobia tells gay people they should be straight, cisnormativity tells nonbinary people they should be cis. That they should “pick a side.” That the space between or beyond the binary is impossible, unsustainable, unacceptable.
But that’s not a mistake.
Science Doesn’t Doubt You, Even When You Doubt Yourself
Here’s the part I wish someone had told you sooner: nonbinary gender identity is not a new phenomenon, not an internet trend, and not a diagnosis. Science — the very science invoked by those who delegitimise you — actually confirms what you feel.
The American Psychological Association (APA) explicitly states that nonbinary gender identities exist and are legitimate. The World Health Organisation (WHO), in the ICD-11 — its most recent classification system — removed “gender dysphoria” as a mental disorder, clearly signalling that being trans or nonbinary is not a pathology.
Research in neuroscience, endocrinology, anthropology, and sociology has shown for decades that gender is a spectrum, not a binary switch. Cultures around the world — from two-spirit communities among Indigenous peoples of North America to hijra communities in South Asia — have recognised gender identities beyond male/female for thousands of years.
What this means: what you feel is not a bug in your operating system. The bug is in the map you were given — a map with only two cities, while you live somewhere between them or beyond that space entirely.
The Body Remembers What Language Can’t Say
Many nonbinary people describe something for which they don’t have an exact word. It’s not always dysphoria. Sometimes it’s a quieter feeling. Mild nausea when someone calls you “ma’am” or “sir.” A twinge in your chest when you’re sorted into the “women” or “men” group at work. A nameless exhaustion from constantly choosing a costume that doesn’t belong to you — or from people asking you to explain what you are.
Your body knows this. It registers the mismatch before you can name it.
In Gestalt therapy, body work isn’t abstract — it’s a simple question: what happens in your body when someone calls you “he” and you know that’s not it? What happens when you look in the mirror and see an image that doesn’t match the internal map? Where in your body do you feel that “no”?
That “no” isn’t a disorder. It’s information. It’s your body speaking truth in a world that asks you to lie.
The Fear of Being “Too Much”
I know what one of the most common inner conversations of nonbinary people looks like. It goes something like this:
“What if I’m overreacting? What if I’m too sensitive? What if other trans people have a right to that identity but I don’t? What if I’m not trans enough? What if I’m just weird?”
That inner conversation — that endless doubt, that measuring of your own legitimacy — is not your nature. It’s the product of a system that gave you only two boxes and told you to fit in one. When you don’t fit, the only conclusion that system offers is: you’re the problem.
But you’re not the problem. The boxes are too small.
Minority stress — the stress that comes from belonging to a marginalised group — takes a specific shape in nonbinary people: it’s not only external. It’s not just discrimination, violence, misunderstanding. It’s also an internal war. Constant questioning: do I have the right to be this? Is my experience “enough”?
And it’s exhausting. Not because you’re weak. But because you’re fighting on two fronts simultaneously — against a world that doesn’t see you, and against yourself for doubting you deserve to be seen.
You Don’t Owe Anyone an Explanation
One of the things I wish nonbinary people would hear — from a therapist, from a parent, a teacher, a friend, from anyone they trust — is this:
You don’t have to explain your identity to make it valid. You don’t have to have a perfect narrative. You don’t need to know “since when” or “why.” You don’t have to look a certain way. You don’t have to use specific pronouns, or change them, or not change them, or explain them.
Your recognition is enough.
Not recognition as a final, finished, defined identity — because identity doesn’t finish. Recognition as a quiet, firm feeling inside that says: this isn’t me. And maybe: this is. And maybe: I don’t know exactly what I am, but I know what I’m not.
And that’s enough. That’s solid ground.
It’s Not a Phase. Not a Trend. Not the Internet.
I need to say this too, because I know that voice exists inside you, or around you, or both.
The voice that says: “It’s because you read too much Tumblr.” “It’s because it’s trendy now.” “It’s because you’re in a bubble.” That voice sounds reasonable — that’s its job. It sounds adult, realistic, composed. It sounds like it’s protecting you from making a mistake.
But what it’s actually protecting you from — is yourself.
Research on minority stress consistently shows that psychological distress in nonbinary people is not a consequence of the identity itself — but of a social context that is particularly merciless toward identities not yet part of the dominant pattern.
Your suffering doesn’t come from who you are. It comes from how much energy you spend pretending to be someone else. From how much space inside you is occupied by the fight for legitimacy instead of living.
What You Carry With You
If nothing else, this: you’re not broken. You’re not defective. You didn’t make yourself up. You’re not a victim of a trend. And you don’t owe anyone an explanation.
What you feel — that tension, that doubt, that nameless discomfort — is not evidence that something is wrong with you. It’s evidence that you’ve been carrying something your whole life that doesn’t belong to you, and your body knows it.
Recognition — quiet, incomplete, imperfect — is not the beginning of a problem. It’s the beginning of honesty.
And you don’t have to go fast. You don’t have to announce. You don’t have to change pronouns, names, wardrobes. You don’t have to do anything. You can just sit with that knowledge and let it exist. Let it breathe a little. Let it take up as much space as it needs.
Because belonging doesn’t begin when the world sees you. Belonging begins when you allow yourself to be seen — even if, at first, only by yourself.
Just stay with who you are for a moment.
If this resonates with you, you don’t have to do anything. The text is yours, no strings attached.
But if you’d like to keep reading things like this, you can sign up for the newsletter — I send occasional reflections, no spam, no pressure.
And if you’re at a point where it would be helpful to talk to someone who won’t ask you to explain yourself — I’m here. I work with individuals and partners, online or in person in Amsterdam.
No rush. No obligation. Just space.